Space, Time, and Imagination Have No Boundaries, But Your unsigned char Does

-
Me next to Tardis Police Box in Kensington, London
When you order a new refrigerator, you:

a) measure the space it will occupy and you walk the delivery path to check the width and height of doorways, hallways, and entry ways.

b) OMG! Take the front door off its hinges!!

c) disassemble the refrigerator outside, and reassemble it inside.

Any answer other than "a" would suggest that you are possibly an overworked programmer who doesn't check boundary conditions.

It would also put you in the same company as the programmers who allowed a killer wallpaper to brick certain Android phones. When installed, this wallpaper would send the phone into an infinite loop, causing it to crash, restart, and then crash again. Even safe mode could not break the cycle.

YouTube tech reviewer, Mrwhosetheboss, played detective in this video, pursuing what he first suspected as malware, but then realizing it to be something more mysterious. He even bricked his own phone in the process.



In the end, it came down to one faulty pixel where the calculated luminosity of 256 exceeded the upper boundary for an unsigned char: 255. This screen shot from his video



shows that the programmers took the ceiling when rounding. As a result, the color engine couldn't convert the pixel luminance to the proper color space, and crashed.

At the 9:40 mark in the video, Mrwhosetheboss says something that would scare a manager I know: "It is a pretty easy one to solve. You just need one line of code that says if this value is above 255, then make it 255."

Without seeing the code or knowing how it might affect the color space, I will nevertheless volunteer one other possible solution: instead of rounding using ceiling, try rounding using floor.

On its own, this bug is minor, rare, and hard to duplicate with other wallpapers. But when integrated into the Android boot up cycle, it can cause a serious malfunction. The lessons here are: 
  1. Unit testing is easy. 
  2. Integration testing is hard.
  3. Check your boundary conditions.
Regarding the photo on top, that's me next to the Tardis Police Box in Kensington, London. Fans of Dr. Who know the Tardis is larger on the inside than the outside, thus transcending space. The Tardis also moves through time, and it took me to June 29, 2016. Well, that's what I like to imagine it did.







Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Bookshelf: UNIX A History and a Memoir

-
Image
  A man page will give you, in black and white, specific information about UNIX. Brian Kernighan's new book adds color and depth about UNIX you won't find anywhere else. I'm not a gray beard (yet), but I imagine they would plow through the book knowingly, but at the same time, learn a few things. Those new to UNIX -- recent college grads or those experimenting with Raspberry Pi -- would be better off starting with Chapter 8 which describes more relatable events and the descendants of UNIX, including Minux and Linux. It's when they start to ask questions like "Where does UNIX come from?" and "Why is Gamora grep?" that they should start from the beginning: Bell Labs, 1969. Kernighan opens with a birds-eye-view of Murray Hill New Jersey, zooms in on the buildings, the offices, the significance of Center 1127, and offers a brief look at some of the key players there. As I progressed through the book, the two factors that made UNIX not just possible, bu
Read more

Bookshelf Classic: The C Programming Language

-
Image
My first job had me programming in Microsoft BASIC for the IBM PC (DOS).  BASIC worked well enough, but its limitations were clear.  The language was interpreted and therefore slow.  More importantly, it wasn't a modern structured language, and instead, relied on line numbers and the GOTO statement.  Anyone who has read Dijkstra knew  GOTO was a bad thing . Having learned a structured language in college ( PL/I ), using BASIC felt unnatural.  When a C compiler became available for the PC, I saw a chance to improve and modernize our software.  The problem was selling the idea -- a problem made harder because I wasn't fluent in C. "It would be a staffing problem.  Not many people know C, but we can find a lot of programmers who know BASIC," noted one manager. The argument was strong as my knowledge of C was weak.  But I knew that C, by design, was a small language and thus easy to learn.  "It has about 30 keywords," I proffered to another manager. U
Read more

Connections

-
Image
Opening a drawer in my hotel room in Toronto, I found this.  I worship at the altar of tech, but I imagine the reaction between two priests might go like this: Mormon Priest:  "At least we're wireless!" Catholic Priest: "And from the very beginning too!"
Read more